Crown lands belong to the public, not government

British Columbians are once again being treated to increased controversy about the management of our Crown land forests – whether it is the decreased role of the chief forester, new threats to remove land from forest reserves or the privatization of the forests themselves.

It is important to remember that the notion of Crown land and not selling off the forest-land base goes back to the very beginnings of land allocation in British Columbia.

The principle of public ownership of B.C.’s forest was firmly established by the House of Assembly before B.C. became a province. We find the view presented and adopted that the selling and granting of large tracts of timberland to companies or individuals should not be entertained, as it is socially injurious and detrimental to settlement.

When land grants were proposed to attract investment in sawmilling, the response was: We will offer licences to cut timber only on unsold and unpreempted land. Thus, leases and licences became the predominant forest tenure.

As a result of this farreaching notion, 94 per cent of British Columbia remains public Crown land. The province, by retaining the land base in public ownership nearly 150 years ago, kept its options open for other public purposes to be met concomitant with timber production.

Citizens of B.C. could continue to enjoy the land, recreate on the trails, raft down the rivers, pick huckleberries and mushrooms, hunt wildlife and fish for salmon, while the revenues generated from these leases and licences would stay within government to build hospitals in our communities, provide education to our children and grandchildren and support art projects and theatre productions.

What a grand model – the government stewards the land for the benefit of the people.

The notion of managing B.C. with a mind to the future, rather than selling the land or moving its responsibility to the private sector, is a vision worthy of continued public support.

However, the current trends are disturbing and leave many people wondering whether the government of today has abandoned this notion of stewarding the land for the future.

Today, B.C.’s Crown lands are being treated more as “government land” that the province can do with what it wants, with seemingly little respect for public ownership, economic sustainability and the Crown’s obligation to honour the claims of First Nations.

The auditor general recently rapped the government’s knuckles: “These forests contribute to employment, tourism and recreational opportunities, as well as generate significant revenue for government to finance public services. However, trends indicate that the future availability of timber will be smaller and less diverse, putting future revenue opportunities at risk.”

Beyond that, a recent report by four retired professionals indicates the budget for resource-related ministries has decreased by 52 per cent in the last 10 years: “There is growing concern, and some evidence, that government and industry are not devoting the level of funding and staffing to renewable resource management that is needed to meet those expectations and responsibilities. Many wonder if the province’s magnificent natural resource legacy is receiving the attention it should.”
In addition, the Forest Practices Board has outlined its concerns about the cumulative effects of resource use on Crown land by the forest industry, mining, oil and gas, and wind power: “What seems to be missing is a well-structured, transparent process for deciding what to do and specifying how to do it.”

The provincial government needs to better manage our lands, biodiversity, forests, and water resources. It needs to develop a strategy that not only addresses employment, tourism and public recreation, but also focuses the government’s financial and staff resources to foster ecological health, economic stability and quality of life for British Columbians now and into the future.

We don’t want to be the generation that fetters the future of our Crown land by selling it and mismanaging its resources. We don’t want to be the generation that “divests” the historic patrimony of our forests, salmon, rivers and wildlife to the degree that successive generations won’t be able to benefit from our Crown lands as envisaged in 1866.

Instead, we must be the generation that identifies what is wrong with the current trends and identifies solutions so that the future management of B.C.’s Crown land is focused on a return to its citizens and its communities.

These changes have been slowly occurring for a long time, seem to have sped up over the last decade and have happened largely without public knowledge.

Indeed, few British Columbians are likely even aware that nearly all the lands and water in the province are publicly owned. There is an urgent need to change our ways and build on this Crown land legacy in a manner that will ensure a healthy economy, a healthy environment and sustainable communities.

Bob Peart is a biologist who has been involved in land use planning, First Nation consultation and park planning and management for more than 30 years.

Read more:  https://www.timescolonist.com/Crown+lands+belong+public+government/6529005/story.html#ixzz1tYxFvzG2

The 'Gnarly Clark'

Let’s name it ‘Protected’

There’s nothing like labelling something with a name to give you that sense of ownership, but the Ancient Forest Alliance has played a clever card this week by naming one of the most at-risk, unprotected old-growth tree groves on the Island after B.C.’s premier.

“Christy Clark Grove” is the newest discovery for the AFA, and currently sits on unprotected public Crown lands not far from Port Renfrew in the Gordon River Valley, just a half-hour drive from the famous Avatar Grove that was recently protected due to public pressure. The grove includes dozens of ancient trees, including Canada’s eighth-widest known Douglas fir, the “Clark Giant,” standing at an enormous 10 feet wide in trunk diameter, and a burly Red Cedar over 13 feet wide, nicknamed the “Gnarly Clark.”

The group hopes the new name will motivate the premier to protect the grove and develop a plan to protect endangered old-growth forests across B.C., instead of supporting their continued destruction.

“We’re hoping that Christy Clark won’t let the ‘Christy Clark Grove’ get cut down, and will show some leadership by creating a plan to protect B.C.’s endangered old-growth forests,” says TJ Watt, AFA photographer and discoverer of the grove. “Already 75 per cent of Vancouver Island’s productive old-growth forests have been logged, including 90 per cent of the biggest trees in the valley bottoms. Why go to the end of an ecosystem when there is an extensive second-growth alternative now to sustain the forest industry?”

The AFA announced the grove after the provincial government released its “BC Forest Strategy” last week, which continues in what the alliance calls “generally destructive status quo policies.” Wood exports to China will be increased, as well as raw log exports and logs from old-growth hemlock-amabilis fir stands. One year ago, the government promised to create a new legal tool to protect B.C.’s largest trees and monumental groves, says AFA head Ken Wu, but so far nothing has materialized. Such a tool, Wu adds, could be used to protect the Christy Clark Grove, and the AFA is calling on Clark to do so.

“We’re still waiting on the B.C. government to show some leadership to create a conservation legacy in B.C. for our endangered old-growth forests, and to end raw log exports,” says Wu. “We want to give credit for good things. But we’re also prepping for a potential major battle in the lead-up to the B.C. election where there will be no prisoners taken, if need be.”

[Monday Mag article no longer available]

Ancient Forest Alliance

Music Video: Holly Arntzen and Kevin Wright – 5ive Sisters

Direct link to YouTube video: https://youtu.be/tp1s7tAVxbs

 

From description:

5ive Sisters story by Holly Arntzen & Kevin Wright.

We moved to Crofton, BC a couple of years ago. Nice place, on a bluff overlooking the sea. The bluff lined by 5 old-growth Arbutus Trees… Holly would dub them, The 5ive Sisters. She started a little song about them… “Standing on a bluff overlooking the sea, 5ive Sisters watching me…” We never thought it would be a full song. It was just something that Holly sang at the house on the piano.

Then she heard about Hans Doliwa, a local, who had quite the story. He agreed to meet for coffee and tell it. You can hear parts of that interview in the intro of the video.

About 20 years ago, Hans was working in the pulp mills in Chemainus and Nanaimo on Vancouver Island. The pulp was put into bales and units and stacked to await shipment
out. One day, the machine that loads and moves the units was pushing a stack of them into place. A stack over 100 yards long. At the end of the stack, way down at the end, a guy sat to eat his lunch. The loader kept pushing and aligning the units into place until finally one got pushed off the end and landed on the guy. Hans and a fellow worker were there. In an adrenaline rush, Hans tried to lift the unit of pulp, weighing in at over 2000 lbs. The unit had the guy crushed right up to his shoulders. Hans heaved upwards enough so the other guy could pull him out. The guy lived.

After some time, the injured man went back to work… but Hans never did. His back was blown out for life after attempting to lift such huge weight. Years went by and Hans had spent the years in a wheelchair. Never working, and constantly battling to be compensated for his injuries.

In Crofton, we have the pleasure of watching raw logs go out to China, the States and elsewhere by giant ship load, right from our yard… as you can see by the footage in the
video. This an ongoing regular occurance. Hans happened to be one man who was just sick of watching this. Logs and jobs being given away. So one day he decided to block the
logging truck entrance to Shoal Island, the dump site for the logs. In his wheelchair, just him, and his dog. He stopped the trucks for less than an hour before he AND his dog got
hauled off by the police. About a year and half later… he did it again.

This song was written as a dedication to a man with a certain amount of bravery and an inner need to stand up for what is right. When you ask him… he doesn’t consider himself anything special, but to us, if more people had his attitude, there might be more positive change happening in this world.

We thought it was worth at least… a song.

Video shot and edited by Kevin Wright
Except studio performance shots by Bob Ennis
Clearcut photography by TJ Watt
Equipment – Panasonic TM900 HD Cam
Avid Studio and a Merlin Pocket Dolly

The 'Gnarly Clark'

Ancient grove named for premier

In honour of Earth Day, the Ancient Forest Alliance is naming a recently found grove of unprotected, near record-size old-growth trees on Vancouver Island the “Christy Clark Grove” after B.C.’s premier. The group hopes the new name will motivate Premier Clark to protect the grove and develop a plan to protect endangered old-growth forests across BC instead of supporting their continued destruction.

“We’re hoping that Christy Clark won’t let the Christy Clark Grove get cut down, and will show some leadership by creating a plan to protect B.C.’s endangered old-growth forests,” stated TJ Watt, Ancient Forest Alliance photographer and campaigner, and discoverer of the Christy Clark Grove. “Already 75 per cent of Vancouver Island’s productive old-growth forests have been logged, including 90 per cent of the biggest trees in the valley bottoms. Why go to the end of an ecosystem when there is an extensive second-growth alternative now to sustain the forest industry?”

The newly found grove is on unprotected public (Crown) lands not far from Port Renfrew, just a half an hour drive from the famous Avatar Grove.

Read more: https://www.sookenewsmirror.com/news/ancient-grove-named-for-premier/

The Clark Giant

Forest Alliance names old growth trees after Premier

The Giant Clark towers over other mighty trees in the Christy Clark Grove near Port Renfrew. In honour of Earth Day, the Ancient Forest Alliance is naming a recently found grove of near record-size old growth trees the “Christy Clark Grove.” Ken Wu with the Ancient Forest Alliance tells us the reason behind the naming.

“We’re hoping to motivate Premier Clark to protect the Christy Clark Grove. It would be unfortunate if she were to allow a grove named after her to get cut down. And, more importantly, I’m hoping that she will develop a plan to protect endangered old growth forests across BC.”

Wu says already 75 per cent of Vancouver Island’s productive old-growth forests have been logged, including 90 per cent of the biggest trees in the valley bottoms.

Original article:   https://www.cfax1070.com

Eco-group hopes premier will protect ‘Christy Clark Grove’

The Ancient Forest Alliance is calling on Premier Christy Cark to protect a newly discovered and endangered old-growth forest that now bears her name.

The Christy Clark Grove — located on unprotected Crown land in the Gordon River Valley near Port Renfrew — rests 500 metres away from a sprawling swath of clearcut Douglas firs and red cedars that AFA co-founder T.J. Watt came across in early April after viewing satellite imagery of some of the last remaining old-growth forests on southern Vancouver Island.

“We’re dealing with the guts and feathers of an incredible rainforest that once covered our island,” Watt, 27, said Saturday from his home in nearby Metchosin.

“By naming this grove after Christy Clark, it helps draw the attention we need to help protect these areas,” he said.

Watt also discovered a Douglas fir with a circumference of 9.5 metres in the grove, making it Canada’s eighth-widest known Douglas fir.

Its name: The Clark Giant.

Watt said he and AFA co-founder Ken Wu are trying to pressure the provincial government into adopting an old-growth policy that will inventory ancient forests growing more scarce on Vancouver Island, the southern mainland of B.C., and the Interior.

The group also wants to see sustainable logging done to 2nd growth forests instead of logging the “biggest, best valley-bottom trees,” said Watts.

According to the AFA, 75 per cent of the Island’s productive old-growth forests have been logged, including 90 per cent of the biggest trees in the valley bottoms.

Christy Clark Grove is not far from Avatar Grove — named and brought to public’s attention by the AFA in December 2009, when some of the trees were due to be harvested.

After an increase in public pressure and an influx of tourists wanting to look at the big trees, the grove was protected by the provincial government.

“[Clark] holds the state of her own grove in her hands,” said Watt. “If she chooses to not protect the endangered Christy Clark Grove, or other old-growth forests, then her own grove will fall.”

Clark could not be reached for comment Saturday.

Read more:    https://www.theprovince.com/news/group+hopes+premier+will+protect+Christy+Clark+Grove/6497702/story.html

Group names old-growth grove after Christy Clark

An endangered forests advocacy group has named an old growth grove after Premier Christy Clark in a move to protect the greenery.

Ancient Forest Alliance said one of the giant trees is recorded as Canada’s eighth largest Douglas fir, and named it the “Clark Giant” on Sunday’s Earth Day.

The “Christy Clark Grove” is located on unprotected Crown land on Vancouver Island in the Gordon River Valley. According to the organization — which is asking the province to create an ‘old-growth strategy’ for B.C. — the ‘Giant’ measures in at three metres in diameter. A second tree, a red cedar nicknamed the ‘Gnarly Clark,’ measures in at four metres wide.

“We’re still waiting on the B.C. government to show some leadership to create a conservation legacy in B.C. for our endangered old-growth forests, and to end raw log exports,” said campaigner Ken Wu.

“We want to give credit for good things. But we’re also prepping for a potential major battle in the lead-up to the B.C. elections where there will be no prisoners taken if need be.”

Clark’s office did not return calls by press time.

Read more:[Original article no longer available]

Christy Clark Grove

Ancient Forest Alliance asks Victoria to protect grove

The Ancient Forest Alliance is appealing to the provincial government to protect endangered old-growth forests by dubbing a recently found grove of massive trees Christy Clark Grove.

The grove, which the AFA found on unprotected Crown land near Port Renfrew, boasts a Douglas fir with a circumference of 9.5 metres, making it the eighth widest known Douglas fir in Canada. The group has nicknamed the fir the Clark Giant and a massive red cedar has been dubbed the Gnarly Clark.

“We’re hoping that Christy Clark won’t let the Christy Clark Grove get cut down and will show some leadership by creating a plan to protect B.C.’s endangered old-growth forests,” said AFA co-founder TJ Watt.

The grove is in the Gordon River valley, not far from Avatar Grove, an area which the AFA brought to public attention shortly before some of the grove was due to be harvested. After public pressure the grove was protected by the provincial government.

Big trees have become an integral part of Port Renfrew’s tourist trade and a boardwalk is being built at Ava-tar Grove to accommodate visitors. However, the province is continuing with an unsustainable forest strategy and has not followed through on a commitment to create a new legal tool to protect B.C.’s largest trees and groves, said AFA co-founder Ken Wu.

Read more:   https://www.vancouversun.com/technology/Ancient+Forest+Alliance+asks+Victoria+protect+grove/6497272/story.html

The Clark Giant

Eco-group hopes premier will protect eponymous grove

 

The Ancient Forest Alliance is appealing to the provincial government to protect endangered old-growth forests by dubbing a recently found grove of massive trees Christy Clark Grove.

The grove, which the AFA found on unprotected Crown land near Port Renfrew, contains a Douglas fir with a circumference of 9.5 metres, making it the eighth-widest known Douglas fir in Canada.

The group has nicknamed the Douglas fir the Clark Giant, while a massive red cedar has been dubbed the Gnarly Clark.

“We’re hoping that Christy Clark won’t let the Christy Clark Grove get cut down and will show some leadership by creating a plan to protect B.C.’s endangered old-growth forests,” said AFA co-founder TJ Watt.

The grove is in the Gordon River Valley, not far from Avatar Grove, an area brought to public attention by the AFA shortly before some of the trees were due to be harvested.

After an increase in public pressure and an influx of tourists wanting to look at the big trees, the grove was protected by the provincial government.

However, AFA co-founder Ken Wu said the province is continuing with an unsustainable forest strategy and has not followed through on a commitment to create a new legal tool to protect B.C.’s largest trees.

Opposition mounts to government talks on opening forest reserves to loggers

The B.C. government is holding talks with the forest industry over ways to supply more timber to beetle-hit Interior sawmills, including the option of opening forest reserves that have until now been out of bounds to loggers.

The discussions have been limited to a few stakeholders who have saw-mills in regions where the mountain pine beetle has devastated the timber supply. But they are raising alarms – even from within the forest industry – that the province is acting unilaterally on issues with sweeping effects on the future of the forests and the communities that depend on them.

The issue of forest reserves has come to the fore after more than a decade of destruction in the woods by the pine beetle. Some sawmills, even the most modern, are going to be shutting down within three to five years unless more timber is found.

A report to be released later this month by the International Wood Markets Group is expected to show that sawmills are running out of economically accessible timber and that another round of mill closures, this time as a result of the beetle rather than the economic downturn, is expected to hit the Interior. The Cari-boo region is expected to be hit particularly hard.

“We don’t have a lot of time on our hands,” said John Allan, president of the B.C. Council of Forest Indus-tries, which represents the Interior industry.

Allan said the industry has been discussing the issue with government but wants a public dialogue on how additional timber supplies can be found. He said he is concerned that as word leaks out about what is under discussion, opposition will galvanize around the hot-button issue of logging in reserves. That could limit rational discussion, he said, noting that some of the timber set aside for visual quality objectives has already been killed by the beetle, making harvesting a more benign option.

“It’s time for the government to get out and get ahead of this issue.”

But logging the reserves is the equivalent of swapping jobs in industries like tourism for jobs in logging, say tourism operators. A forests minis-try study showed tourists view dead, grey trees as part of a natural cycle. Clearcuts do not evoke the same sentiments, Eric Loveless executive director of the Wilderness Tourism Association said in an April 4 letter to the government.

Much of the concern over revisiting decisions that were made a decade ago to protect forest lands is coming from foresters themselves. Reserves under consideration include everything from set-asides to maintain visual quality, to wildlife patches and old-growth management areas.

“We have maintained those old-growth areas or reserves for a variety of purposes. They are lifeboats of bio-logical diversity across the landscape,” said Mike Larock, director of professional practice and forest steward-ship for the Association of B.C. Forest Professionals. “They are important contributors and they occupy a very small percentage of the land base.”

Sharon Glover, association chief executive officer, said foresters are concerned that sustaining mills, not forest health, appears to be driving the government initiative.
 

The province’s 5,000 forest professionals have not been part of the discussions, she said.

“We are disturbed by the quickness and by the very small number of people that have been included in these discussions.

“What’s missing from our perspective is the focus on the forest. The forest is the wealth of B.C.,” she said. “When you have a healthy forest, then you have a number of mills that spring up and use that wood. If it is well-managed and sustainably man-aged, as B.C.’s forests have been, then forestry and those small communities in rural B.C. will prosper.

“If you don’t focus on the forest, and you focus on the mills, that’s when you’ve got the equation backwards. The mountain pine beetle took 10 years worth of merchantable timber out of B.C. We don’t have the luxury of not focusing on our forests.”

The reserves were set aside in land-use plans arrived at in some cases after years of confrontation and community involvement. During work on the Cariboo-Chilcotin Land Use Plan, for example, at one point an angry crowd hung in effigy commissioner Stephen Owen, who headed that land-use pro-cess, forcing cancellation of that particular meeting.

Now, said Glover, she fears short-term decisions may be made based on short-term economics.

“Decisions were made quite a while ago to protect certain areas. They were really good reasons. A lot of thought was put into it. We need to have broad discussions and serious, open discussions about what data are out there, what fibre is out there. We would argue that the focus has to be on the forests and whether they are healthy or not, and whether what the government may be proposing is good, sustainable forestry.”

However, Jobs, Tourism and Innovation Minister Pat Bell said that maybe it’s time some of those decade-old decisions were revisited in light of the changes to the landscape the beetle has wrought.

Bell, who was forests minister for three years, is leading the review of timber supplies along with current Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations Minister Steve Thomson.

Bell justified the province’s decision to proceed with limited public engagement because the data are still being collected.

“I don’t think anyone should assume that there is in any way an exclusionary effort going on here. Government needs to understand what options are available to it.”

“Until we have good information that we can then sit down and provide to people who care about the region, then it’s really premature to have those discussions.”

He said those open discussions could begin within a month or two.

The issue of coping with the fall-down in what the forests ministry calls the midterm timber supply – the amount of timber available during the time it will take for the beetle-killed forests to recover – was initially raised last September by the Union of B.C. Municipalities.

UBCM passed a resolution urging the province to do a cost-benefits analysis of the impact reserves – such as those set aside for visual quality objectives and for wildlife tree patches – are having on the timber supply for mills.
 

However, a fire last December that destroyed the Burns Lake sawmill and killed two sawmill workers, prompted the government to move more quickly on the timber supply issue.

The province has conducted a timber review in the Burns Lake forest district which, Bell said, has shown there is an additional 100,000 cubic metres of wood available if the mill should be rebuilt.

However, there are concerns outside government that that is not enough additional timber to justify a modern new mill.

Independent MLA Bob Simpson said a modern mill requires a diet of one million cubic metres of timber a year. The province would need to make the entire land base available to logging, he speculated.

Allan said the forest industry under-stands the concern at Burns Lake. The depth of the situation compels the government to act, he said, but he expressed concern that if the government searches outside the Burns Lake timber supply for additional wood, it may only pass the pain on to another community and another sawmill.

“I know the government is looking for incremental timber supplies. If there is enough timber, great; if there isn’t, then you can’t manufacture a new sawmill or an extension of a mill that needs to be rationalized with government subsidies and other forms of assistance. It’s not what we have been doing for the last few years and that has led to a smaller industry. But it is very efficient and very competitive.

“And that’s what you need in the world markets.”

Read more: https://www.vancouversun.com/business/Opposition+mounts+government+talks+opening+forest+reserves+loggers/6459824/story.html